Niagara
Region Anti-Racism Association 2026 Municipal Election Survey
Download our survey for school trustee
candidates here.
Download our survey for all other
municipal election candidates here.
Last update: September 16
Please check back for the answers we
receive and special notes on candidates. We will be publishing answers on a
rolling basis.
Survey question topic codes:
“white
supremacists”: Condemning white supremacist groups active locally
“Hitler debacle”: autographed Mein Kampf scandal
“Anti-Indigenous comments”: Anti-Indigenous comments at
Niagara Falls Council
“Palestine”: Support for Palestine vs Support for Israel,
Ukraine
“Niagara Police”: systemic racism in Niagara Regional Police
Service
“suspension rates”: special
question for trustees: publishing suspension rates by race
Shortcut by role:
Shortcut to questions white supremacists
Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments
Palestine Niagara Police
Shortcut to questions white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Shortcut to questions white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Shortcut to questions white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
DSBN (English public) Trustee (1)
Shortcut to questions suspension rates white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
NCDSB (English Catholic) Trustee (1)
Shortcut to questions suspension rates
white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Shortcut to questions suspension rates white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Shortcut to questions suspension rates white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Special notes on candidates
(to come)
Shortcut to questions white supremacists
Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments
Palestine Niagara Police
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
Back to mayor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl
Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl
Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl
Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
Back to mayor top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl
Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
Back to mayor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl
Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
Back to mayor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Greg Reimer |
Response not received yet |
|
Adam Thomas
Russell |
Response not received yet |
|
Cheryl
Keddy-Scott |
Response not received yet |
Back to mayor top
Back to page top
Shortcut to questions white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
The Niagara
Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split hair” to
condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying Indigenous
evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Dianne
Rintjema |
Response not received yet |
|
Canaan
El-Hassan |
Response not received yet |
|
Justin Zegers |
Response not received yet |
|
Carlo Filice |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Councillor – Ward 2
Shortcut to questions white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie Gervason |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie
Gervason |
Response not received yet |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie
Gervason |
Response not received yet |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie
Gervason |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie
Gervason |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie
Gervason |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Tony G.
Brunet |
Response not received yet |
|
John D. Pachereva |
Response not received yet |
|
Natalie
Gervason |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Shortcut to questions white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d. Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Mike Mikolic |
Response not received yet |
|
Lynn Timmers |
Response not received yet |
|
Shawn Stryker |
Response not received yet |
Back to Councillor top
Back to page top
Shortcut to questions suspension rates white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Special question for trustee candidates:
Niagara-related school boards have
not published suspension rates by race, which neighbouring school boards have, showing Black students
are disproportionately suspended.
Will you advocate and vote for
publishing suspension rates by race data within a year of being elected?
a. Yes
b. No
c.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
a.
Yes |
Back to DSBN top
Back to page top
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
b. Commit
to publicly condemning these groups, now as a candidate, and as an elected
official, and to advocating that the government body you are elected to
condemn these groups publicly |
Back to DSBN top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
a.
Yes |
Back to DSBN top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre
in condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism. |
Back to DSBN top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis |
Back to DSBN top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Nick Goater |
Response not received yet |
|
Deb Pearce |
Response not received yet |
|
Duncan Storey |
Response not received yet |
|
Luca Vitali |
a. Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people |
Back to DSBN top
Back to page top
NCDSB (English Catholic) Trustee
Shortcut to questions suspension rates
white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Special question for trustee candidates:
Niagara-related school boards have
not published suspension rates by race, which neighbouring school boards have, showing Black students
are disproportionately suspended.
Will you advocate and vote for
publishing suspension rates by race data within a year of being elected?
a. Yes
b. No
c.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
a.
Yes |
Back to NCDSB top
Back to page top
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups,
now as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly |
Back to NCDSB top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
c.
No |
Back to NCDSB top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
d.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre
in condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism. |
Back to NCDSB top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
c.
All
people, cultures, religions are important and vital for society. I believe
these issues should be left to levels of government that deal directly with
them. Individuals have their own voices and opinions, and all should be
respectfully shared.I will
work with our schools and administration to ensure all students, families,
staff and stakeholders feel welcome and included. |
Back to NCDSB top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Lynn Dudok |
Response not received yet |
|
Alex Joyner |
Response not received yet |
|
Leanne Prince |
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara
Regional Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an
apology and addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black
people As a society, we always will be
looking to improve. I will continue to advocate for our students and schools
to be safe, inclusive and welcoming to all students, staff and stakeholders. |
Back to NCDSB top
Back to page top
Shortcut to questions suspension rates white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Special question for trustee candidates:
Niagara-related school boards have
not published suspension rates by race, which neighbouring school boards have, showing Black students
are disproportionately suspended.
Will you advocate and vote for
publishing suspension rates by race data within a year of being elected?
a. Yes
b. No
c.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSV top
Back to page top
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSV top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSV top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSV top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSV top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Sonia
Macaluso |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSV top
Back to page top
Shortcut to questions suspension rates white supremacists Hitler Debacle Anti-Indigenous comments Palestine Niagara Police
Special question for trustee candidates:
Niagara-related school boards have
not published suspension rates by race, which neighbouring school boards have, showing Black students
are disproportionately suspended.
Will you advocate and vote for
publishing suspension rates by race data within a year of being elected?
a. Yes
b. No
c.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSM top
Back to page top
White
supremacist groups like the Dominion Society are postering across Niagara
promoting mass deportations (rebranded as “remigration” even though they want
to deport non-migrants i.e. citizens as well). Until recently some
municipalities like St. Catharines deliberately avoided publicly addressing
this out of concern it would incentivize these groups to increase their
activity. Other cities like Hamilton have publicly condemned hate groups like
the Dominion Society, and last week were joined by West Lincoln, Grimsby,
Lincoln, and the mayor of St. Catharines.
Do you:
a.
Believe it’s better not to give attention to
these groups by condemning them
b.
Commit to publicly condemning these groups, now
as a candidate, and as an elected official, and to advocating that the
government body you are elected to condemn these groups publicly
c.
Believe these are not white supremacist groups
or there is nothing wrong with their postering
d.
Support the idea of “remigration” promoted by
these groups
e.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSM top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council Chair Bob Gale resigned mere hours after he was exposed for
buying, owning, and authenticating Nazi memorabilia. The mayors of Niagara
Falls and Pelham said he did nothing wrong and is just a collector, while the
mayor of St. Catharines said this was a distraction from “really important”
things. Very few elected officials condemned Bob Gale.
Do you:
a.
Condemn Bob Gale for owning Nazi memorabilia
b.
Believe Bob Gale did nothing wrong
c.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Do you also:
a.
Believe this scandal is a distraction from
“really important” issues
b.
Believe top officials collecting autographed
hate propaganda like Mein Kampf is a “really important” issue and
racism, not a distraction
c.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
At a press conference on April 2nd Minister
Flack was asked how
another “Hitler debacle” could be avoided. Can you confirm you do not have,
nor have you ever had, nor will you ever have, Nazi memorabilia?
a.
Yes
b.
No
c.
It’s your personal business or doesn’t matter
d.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSM top
Back to page top
The
Niagara Falls mayor said it was “out of context,” “misconstrued,” and a “split
hair” to condemn comments by the ex-CAO at a City Council meeting saying
Indigenous evacuees out in public would be seen as “homeless” by residents.
Statements by
the Kashechewan, Nishnawbe
Aski Nation, Chiefs
of Ontario, and Niagara
Regional Native Centre condemned the ex-CAO’s comments for reinforcing
stereotypes and ignoring that all Indigenous peoples have every right to be on
their own land.
Do you:
a.
Believe the ex-CAO’s comments were taken “out of
context,” “misconstrued,” or a “split hair”
b.
Agree with the Kashechewan,
Nishnawbe Aski Nation, Chiefs of Ontario, and Niagara Regional Native Centre in
condemning the ex-CAO’s comments for amplifying racism.
c.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSM top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Council and several municipalities like St. Catharines, Welland, Grimsby, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Thorold and Lincoln
have passed motions supporting Ukraine, and some motions supported military
escalation.
Niagara
Regional Councillors also unanimously “sanctioned” themselves from Russia,
which is not how sanctions against individuals work.
Niagara
Regional Council also lit their “Everyone Welcome” sign in Israel’s colours and
the City of St. Catharines officially sided with Israel (“rally for Israel”) in
a statement by a city councillor on behalf of the mayor.
Yet many
elected officials said expressing similar support for Palestinians is out of
their jurisdiction, would be divisive, or would be traumatizing.
Do you:
a.
Believe Palestine is not a municipal issue and
so should not be addressed, though Ukraine and Israel are
b.
Believe governments should express support for
Palestinians, they did for Ukrainians and Israelis
c.
Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSM top
Back to page top
Niagara
Regional Police have had the second worst disproportional use of force against
Black people (% of use of force incidents vs % of population) in the province
since publishing this data was required by the Ontario Anti-Racism Act. It has
been up to almost 10x disproportional: in
2025, 26% of the use of force was against Black people who were less than 3% of
the population in the 2021 census. This is the same as Minneapolis, where
George Floyd was murdered, which the US Department of Justice called
“discriminatory.”
Neighbouring
police forces such as Hamilton, Peel and Toronto, who are less disproportional
than Niagara, have apologized for their own systemic racism in their
disproportional use of force.
Yet the Police
Chief, when he was Deputy Chief, said the data shows there is
no systemic racism in the Niagara Police. One Police Board member who is
running for mayor of Wainfleet had said in 2020 as a Niagara Regional
Councillor that systemic racism is a “shadowy term…bandied about.”
To our
knowledge none of the Police Board members have mentioned disproportional use
of force against Black people, including the Board Chair who used to be co-chair
of the Police Chief’s Community Inclusion Council, and one Board member who is
a Regional Councillor and chairs the Niagara Regional Council’s Diversity
Equity Inclusion Advisory Committee.
Do you:
a.
Condemn systemic racism in the Niagara Regional
Police based on their own use of force by race data and call for an apology and
addressing the disproportional use of force by race against Black people
b.
Believe data does not show systemic racism in
the Niagara Regional Police
c.
Believe “systemic racism” is a “shadowy
term…bandied about”
d.
Both b and c
e. Other:
|
Melinda
Chartrand |
Response not received yet |
Back to CSM top
Back to page top